The Herald discusses the subject
and shows in the same manner how dependence
upon San Francisco worked ill to all
Oregonians. It said:
"We have frequently urged upon our citizens
the importance of establishing a foreign
commerce and an independent trade for
Oregon. Every intelligent man, on first
becoming acquainted with the vast natural
resources and commercial facilities of
Oregon, is struck with astonishment at the
apparent want of enterprise exhibited by the
business men of this section in the matter
of foreign commerce. A few days ago we
noticed a sale of flour from the Salem mills
at the highest market price; it was quoted
in the printed reports as `California
flour.' A gentleman of this city has just
shown us a letter from his agent in New
York, advising him of a sale of flour from
the mill situated at Jefferson, in Marion
county, Oregon, at the highest market rates.
That is put down in the commercial report as
`California flour.' Neither the name of
Portland nor Oregon is noticed in commercial
intelligence. Steamers and sailing vessels
loaded for Portland appear in the shipping
report as `cleared for the Columbia.' The
imports of foreign goods to San Francisco
upon which duties were paid at that port,
amounted to $17,987,535.00, for the year
1867. The imports from the eastern States
during the same year were not less than as
much more; which would make an aggregate of
imports of $35,975,070. Not less than
one-third of that entire amount was
re-shipped to the Columbia, passing through
Portland for a market---say, eleven million
one hundred and ninety-nine thousand one
hundred and seventy-two dollars. The San
Francisco commission upon this amount was at
least ten per cent.---$1,199,-927. The
freight from San Francisco to Portland upon
these goods was not less than $400,000.
Allowing the same amount for commission and
return freights, and it will he found that
our trade with San Francisco in commission
and freights costs $3,198,344. Goods can be
shipped directly from New York and Boston,
or from any foreign port to- Portland for
one dollar a ton more than for San
Francisco. By direct trade with the east and
foreign ports, we have a saving of $700,000
in freights, and $2,398,344 in commissions
and charges incident to breaking bulk,
re-selling and re-shipping, at San
Francisco. During the past two years
Portland has paid tribute to San Francisco
to an amount more than equal to the value of
all assessable property. San Francisco has
now a population of a hundred and
twenty-five thousand. Port-land, with a
foreign and independent commerce, with the
same spirit of enterprise, which has
characterized the former city, would now
number not less than fifty thousand. This
proposition is now mathematically
demonstrable. The mines naturally tributary
to Portland are greater in extent and
product than those to San Francisco; the
agricultural products of Oregon are more
certain, and as available as those of
California. Our lumber, iron and coal---the
three great staples of commerce ---together
with our manufacturing facilities, are
infinitely superior to those of California;
we are nearer to the rich commerce of the
Indies, and in the direct line of the
shortest practicable, belt of commerce
around the world, when the contemplated
railroad systems are completed. With all
these superior natural advantages, why do we
consent to be a mere dependency? Paying
tribute to the amount of one-third of our
earnings to a city which constantly strives
to humble and degrade us ?"
The estimates of the amount Portland was
then paying to San Francisco, as given by
the Herald, were probably excessive,
but the reasoning presented was sound and
weighty, and had a good effect among its
constituents, as the like presentations of
the Oregonian and other journals upon
their readers.
About this time there were others also
striving valiantly for release from these
restrictions. Among these was Mr. Robert
Kinney, who, although not a citizen of
Portland, had interests here; and, as the
proprietor of large grist mills, was seeking
a market for the products of his
manufacture. His son, Marshall J. Kinney, at
that time his agent in California; found it
extremely difficult to charter a ship for
crossing the bar independently of the
California companies. He was met with all
manner of preposterous objections, and he
found the prevailing opinions in regard to
the Columbia river prejudiced by
self-interest, and even dense ignorance.
Nevertheless, he succeeded in chartering a
bark-the Cutwater-and the cargo shipped on
her was among the first, if not the very
first, to sail away independently of
California.
As the people of Portland became thus moved,
measures were introduced in the State
Legislature, which convened in the latter
part of 1868, to provide relief. Col. W. W.
Chapman, still at the front in all matters
relating to the prosperity of Portland,
undertook the passage of a bill for a tug
off the Columbia bar. His first step was to
remove the prejudices of the agricultural
members, who were naturally quite loth to
vote money out of the State treasury for the
benefit of Portland; but the Colonel was
able to show them that, as their groceries,
farm machinery, clothing and other
necessaries were taxed heavily by coming
through San Francisco, anything to open up
direct communication with New York would
result in their advantage. In order to prove
that there must be some assistance given to
shipping, he showed that although there was
a depth of twenty-four feet on the Columbia
bar at dead low water-which, at the time,
was the case-the dangers resulted from lack
of uncertainty of winds; and every disaster
has been due to such failure. He showed that
shippers and ship owners would refuse to
dispatch vessels to this port while this
embarrassment remained. He recommended that
the State give a subsidy for the maintenance
of a proper steam tug at the mouth of the
river. To show that such subsidy was
necessary, he cited the experience of
Captain Paul Corno, who had some years
before attempted to maintain a. tug, but
found that the business was not large enough
to justify his endeavor. Chapman's
recommendations were adopted, a subsidy of
thirty thousand dollars was provided-to be
furnished under proper restriction and in
certain yearly installments-and the rates of
pilotage were reduced twenty-five per cent.
The tug boat was allowed, when not needed at
the bar, to tow vessels to Portland.
Steps were also taken by the merchants of
Portland, and by the city as a corporation,
to maintain a dredger on the lower
Willamette river, and a channel three
thousand two hundred feet in length was cut
to a depth of fifteen feet at low water,
across Swan Island bar, at an expenditure of
some twenty-five thousand dollars.
As a result of all these endeavors, a new
and steady commerce began to spring up. The
Packet line from New York continued regular
trips, although, as the transcontinental
railways were constructed, the need of them
has very largely ceased. The commerce with
foreign ports, and particularly with the
United Kingdom, has, however, grown steadily
from that day to this.
The following table of the exports to San
Francisco for 1869 shows the progress of our
commerce. It is very incomplete, being much
like the others in this regard, as given
heretofore:
| Treasure | $2, 358, 000 00 | Salmon, barrels | 1,937 |
| Bullion | 419,657 00 | Salmon, packages | 19,729 |
| Butter,packages | 1,313 | Flour, quarter sacks | 543 |
| Hides | 5,650 | Wheat, sacks | 49,422 |
| Wool, bales | 3,191 | Oats, sacks | 58,403 |
| Barley, sacks | 240 | Bacon, gunnies | 4,723 |
| Pork, barrels | 1,712 | Lard, half barrels | 2,960 |
| Cheese, packages | 12 | Apples, boxes | 31,520 |
| Hams, packages | 435 | Dried apples, packages | 4,912 |
| Pig iron, tons | 825 |
Of the items above mentioned, it will be
noticed that treasure is rapidly decreasing,
while flour, wheat and salmon are
increasing. Iron appears for the first time
in any noticeable quantity, and gives proof
of the industry established at Oswego.
Salmon, as shipped in
cases or packages, witnesses the beginning
of the great industry about springing up in
canning this noble fish. Although salmon
were not shipped from Portland exclusively,
nor perhaps to a very large extent, and
although the business of canning was not
operated with Portland capital, nevertheless
the income from this resource had a decided
effect in stimulating business at this
point.
The aggregate of sales in the city is
estimated at $3,400,000 for this year, and
the internal revenue collections were
$204,532.
In 1870 the commerce to the United Kingdom
begins to rise. In that year, in the months
from July 1st, 1869, to November, 1870, the
exports thither amounted to a value of about
$61,000.
The following table exhibits the export to
San Francisco :
| Apples, boxes | 25,600 | Salmon, bbls | 3,792 |
| Flour, quarter sacks | 144,071 | Salmon, half bbls | 4,746 |
| Lumber, feet | 6,818,547 | Salmon, cases | 22,130 |
| Oats, sacks | 63,235 |
It appears that in the year 1870 no
statistics were kept at Portland of exports,
and of the above meagre table the Oregonian
speaks as follows: "It is but just to this
State to say, however, that the above
figures do not for either year (1869-70)
express the full amount of our shipment to
San Francisco, but only such amounts of the
various articles as were shipped into the
San Francisco market for sale. It is well
known that during each year we sent
considerable quantities of wheat, flour,
salmon, etc., to San Francisco for shipment
to Eastern or foreign ports; these were not
included in the above table. The very small
increase of wheat exports of 1870 above 1869
is accounted for by the fact that in 1869 we
shipped but little to foreign countries
direct, while in 1870 we exported to foreign
countries as much as, or more than, appears
in this table. The latest shipment to all
destinations would show that our grain and
breadstuffs export have increased greatly
more in proportion than any other products.
It will be seen that exports of salmon have
also increased."
The exports to foreign countries - including
China, British Columbia, Sandwich Islands,
England, Ireland, Uruguay and Peru
aggregated a value of three hundred and
seventy-one thousand three hundred and
fifty-five dollars-mostly lumber, flour and
fish.
The statistics of 1870 appear incomplete and
unsatisfactory-showing negligence on the
part of the Portland shippers of that time.
The foreign commerce during that period does
not seem to have advanced quite so rapidly
as was hoped, and the Portland merchants
appear to have been somewhat slow to make
use of the great advantages open to them by
the new order of things. Nevertheless, this
was but natural, as the capital was not then
in the city to inaugurate a great
enterprise, and must be brought in from
abroad. The Customs District of Willamette
was created and a Custom House established
at Portland this year.
This was, moreover, a period of railroad
building and excitement, and, consequently,
foreign commerce by water was not so rapidly
pushed. Still further, the producers of the
country, the farmers, lumbermen and
stock-raisers, must adapt their industries
more directly to commerce, and not consider
it a simple addendum to conveniently provide
to take care of what they happened to have
left over of their domestic industries.
In 1871 foreign exports rise to a value of
$692,297. Clearing to foreign ports are
found five foreign ships, aggregating three
thousand, seven hundred tons, and six
foreign barks, two thousand, six hundred
tons. Of American steamer clearances to
foreign ports, there were twenty-nine, and
six barks and one schooner, aggregating
sixteen thousand tons. Imports from foreign
countries reached $517,633.
The coastwise arrivals, from San Francisco
and other American cities, aggregated
eighty-six thousand four hundred and sixteen
tons.
In 1872 we find commerce rising to something
like its contemplated proportions. For its
purposes, eighteen American steamers and
eight barks were employed, with a tonnage of
eleven thousand, nine hundred and forty-six;
and of foreign vessels, twelve barks and two
schooners, aggregating nine thousand, one
hundred and forty tons.
Imports from England reached a value of
$350,980; from British Columbia, $31,294;
from Sandwich Islands, $171,332; from
Hongkong, $115,338; from other .points,
$59,831, making a total of $728,825. The
large imports from the Sandwich Islands show
the value of their trade to Portland, if
their products of sugar might be somehow
taken away, at least in part, from the San
Francisco monopoly.
The exports for this year were as follows:
To England, a value of $3,041,744; British
Columbia, $107,508; Ireland, $187,549;
Sandwich Islands, $8,824; Hongkong, $33,925,
making a total of $642,620.
The wheat shipped to the United Kingdom from
August 1st to December 13th reached 209,337
centals, worth $311,166, as against 99,463
centals, worth $257,276 in 1871. There were
five vessels engaged in this trade, while in
1872 there were ten. The value of the grain
thus exported did not keep pace with that of
the year before, on account of the low price
realized. The export to California of flour
was 192,500 sacks.
As for coast-wise traffic, there were
eighty-two steamers, twenty barks, three
brigs, four ships and various schooners,
aggregating a hundred and nine thousand,
nine hundred and forty-seven tons.